Re-evaluation of Scrapers Reduction Model Using Geometric Index of Reduction (Mar-Tarik Middle Paleolithic Assemblages)

Document Type : Research Article

Authors

1 Department of Archaeology, Tarbiat Modares University, Tehran, Iran

2 Department of Archaeology, Islamic Azad University, Dezful Branch, Dezful, Iran

Abstract

Paleolithic lithic assemblages are traditionally described on the bases of presence of a variety of tool types
(typology) and of different knapping technologies. In this study we tried to investigate whether the presence of
different groups of scrapers in the Mar-Tarik site assigned to the Middle Paleolithic represent specific function or
just different stages of the reduction process and constant changes as the result of accessibility to the raw
materials. In this research Dibble's scrapers reduction model which was proposed for the first time based on
Bisitun rock shelter Middle Paleolithic assemblages, was tested using the Geometric Index of Reduction method
for the unifacial scrapers. The results indicate that similarities in the dimensions of the different types of scrapers
in Mar-Tarik and Bisitun might be a result of using small size raw materials. Meantime different functional
aspects of these two sites might have been responsible for differences in the intensity of retouch on their artifacts.

Keywords

References

Baumler, M. F & J. D. Speth.1993 A Middle Paleolithic Assemblage fromKunji Cave, Iran. In Deborah I. Olszewski
& Harold L. Dibble, (eds.) The PaleolithicPrehistory of the Zagros-Taurus: 1-73.
Philadelphia: The University Museum.University of Pennsylvania.
Biglari, F.2000 Report of new found Paleolithic sites inBisitun. Archeology & History Magazine2: 50-60
Bordes, F.1961 Typologie du Paleolithique Ancient et M oyen.Cahiers du Quaternaire N. 1. Bordeaux:
Institut de Quaternaire, Universite deBordeaux.
Brumma, A & A. McLarenb.2010 (In press) Scraper reduction and “imposedform” at the Lower Palaeolithic site of
High Lodge, England. Journal of HumanEvolution.
Coon, C.S.1951 Cave Explorations in Iran 1949. MuseumMonographs. Philadelphia: The UniversityMuseum. University of Pennsylvania.
1952 Excavation in Hotu, Iran 195. APreliminary Report (With Section on theArtifacts by L.B. Dupree and the Human
Skeletal Remains by J.L.Angel ).Proceedings of the American PhilosophicalSociety 96:231-269.
Dibble, H. L.1984a Interpreting Typological Variation ofMiddle Paleolithic Scrapers: Function,Style, or Sequence of Reduction? Journalof field Archaeology 11:431-436.
1984b The Mousterian Industry from Bisitun Cave(Iran). Paléorient 10:23-34.
1987 The interpretation of Middle Paleolithicscraper morphology. American Antiquity52:109-117.
1991 Mousterian assemblage variability on aninterregional scale. Journal ofAnthropological Research 47:239-257.
1995 Middle Paleolithic Scraper Reduction:Background, Clarification, and Review ofthe Evidence to Date. J.Arch.Method andTheory 2: 299-368.
Eren, M. I & G. Sampson.2009 Kuhn's geometric index of unifacial stonetool reduction (GIUR): does it measure
missing flake mass? Journal ofArchaeological Science 36:1243-1247.
Heydari, S.2007 The impact of geology and geomorphologyon cave and rock shelter archaeological siteformation, preservation, and distribution inthe Zagros Mountains of Iran.Geoarchaeology 22(6): 653-669.
Hiscock, P & C. Clarkson.2005 Experimental Evaluation of Kuhn ́sGeometric Index of Reduction and the Flat-Flake problem. J. Arch. Sci. 32: 1015-1022.
2008 The construction of morphological diversity.In W. Andrefsky (ed.) Lithic Technology:Measures of Production, Use, and Curation:106-135. Cambridge: Cambridge UniversityPress.
Hole, F & K. V. Flannery.1967 The Prehistory of Southwestern Iran: APreliminary Report. Proceedings of thePrehistoric Society 33: 147-206.
Jaubert, J & F. Biglari.2004 Paleolithic of Iran. French ArchaeologicalMission in Iran (Paleolithic period).
Jaubert, J; F. Biglari; V. Mourre; L. Bruxelles; J. G.Bordes; S. Shidrang; R. Naderi; M. Mashkour; B.Maureille; J. B. Mallye; Y. Quinif; W. Rendu & V.Laroulandie.2009 The Middle Paleolithic Occupation of Mar-Tarik, a New Zagros Mousterian Site. In M.Otte; F. Biglari & J. Jaubert (eds.) IranPaleolithic: 7-28. BAR International Series1968.
Kuhn, S. L.1990 Ageometric index of reduction for unifacialstone tools. Journal of ArchaeologicalScience 17: 583-593.
1992 Blank from and reduction as determinantsof Mousterian scraper morphology.American Antiquity 57: 115-128.
1995 Mousterian Lithic Technology: AnEcological Perspective. Princeton:Princeton University Press.
Lindly, J. M.1997 The Zagros Mousterian: a regionalPerspective. Unpublished Ph.D.dissertation, Department of Anthropology,Arizona State University. Tempe (AZ).
Mellars, P.1996 The Neanderthal Legacy. Princeton:Princeton University Press.
Smith, P.E. L.1986 Paleolithic archaeology in Iran. AmericanInstitute of Iranian Studies. Monograph I.Philadelphia: University of PennsylvaniaMuseum.
Stringer, C & C. Gamble.1993 In Search of the Neanderthals, solving thepuzzle of human origins. London: Thames
and Hudson.
Trinkaus, E & F. Biglari.2006 Middle Paleolithic Human Remains fromBisitun Cave, Iran. Paléorient 32 (2):
105-111.
Young, T.C, Jr & P.G L., Smith.1966 Research in the Prehistory of CentralWestern Iran. Science 153:386-91.

Files

Share

How to cite

Statistics