Petrographic Analysis of the 6th Millennium B.C. Dalma Ceramics from Northwestern and Central Zagros

Document Type : Research Article

Author

Department of Anthropology, Yale University, USA

Abstract

Sixth millennium BC Dalma ceramics from the northwestern and central Zagros have previously been described as being
impossible to distinguish using decorative style analysis in spite of the great distance between the two regions. In this
study, petrographic (thin section) analysis and a small-scale electron microprobe project was carried out on the ceramics
of the two regions, as well as a small sample of the preceding and following Hajji Firuz and Pisdeli period ceramics.
The petrographic analysis of microstructure reveals minute differences in manufacturing techniques. The results suggest
that the Dalma ceramics were a distinct ceramic group with a great degree of variability, suggesting that they were
made locally at the household level by individual potters and their preferences for ceramic manufacturing techniques.
However, there was enough communication between the different regions to keep the stylistic and to a certain degree
ceramic manufacturing technique uniform over this wide area. The analyses suggest that Dalma ceramics were spread
by small groups of nomadic pastoralists who maintained a relationship with the agricultural Dalma villages. In this way,
petrographic analysis of ceramics and geospatial analysis allow for a better understanding of the distribution of Dalma
ceramics, and suggest the role of nomadic populations in their spread.

Keywords


Dean E; Prudence M. Rice; William A. Jester,Warren N. Deutsch, Bong K. Lee, and Richard I. Kirsch.
1978 Neutron Activation Analysis of ContemporaryPottery and Pottery Materials from the Valleyof Guatemala. In Ronald K. Wetherington,(ed.) The Ceramics of Kaminaljuyu,Guatemala: 543-586. The Pennsylvania StateUniversity Press.
Barth, Fredrik.1961 Nomads of South Persia: The Basseri Tribe ofthe Khamseh Confederacy. Boston: Little,Brown andCompany.
 
1962 Nomadism in the mountain and plateau areasof South West Asia. In Unesco (ed.) TheProblems of the Arid Zone: Proceedings ofthe Paris Symposium: 341-355. Paris: UnitedNations.
Berman, Judith.1994 The Ceramic Evidence for SociopoliticalOrganization in ‘Ubaid Southwestern Iran.In Gil Stein & Mitchell S. Rothman (eds.)Chiefdoms and Early States in the Near East:The Organizational Dynamics of Complexity:
23-33. Madison: Prehistory Press.
Bishop, Ronald L & Hector Neff.1989 Compositional Data Analysis in Archaeology.
Archaeological Chemistry 4: 57-86.
Burney, Charles A & David M. Lang.1971 The Peoples of the Hills: Ancient Ararat andCaucasus. New York: Praeger.
Buxeda i Garrigos, Jaume.1999 Alteration and Contamination ofArchaeological Ceramics: The Perturbation
Problem. Journal of Archaeological Science26: 295-313.
Buxeda i Garrigos, Jaume; Vassilis Kilikoglou & PeterM. Day.2001 Chemical and Mineralogical Alteration of
Ceramics from a Late Bronze Age Kiln
at Kommos, Crete: The Effect on the
Formation of a Reference Group.
Archaeometry 43: 349-371.
Cau Ontiveros, Miguel A; Peter M. Day & Giuseppe
Montana.
2002 Secondary Calcite in Archaeological
Ceramics: Evaluation of Alteration and
Contamination Processes by Thin Section
Study. In Kilikoglou Vassilis; Anno Hein &
Yannis Maniatis (eds.) Modern Trends in
Scientific Studies on Ancient Ceramics: 9-18.
Oxford: Archaeopress.
Childe, V. Gordon.
1936 Man Makes Himself. New York: Oxford
Univeristy Press.
Cole, Donald Powell.
1975 Nomads of the Nomads: The Al MurrahBedouin of the Empty Quarter. Aldine
Publishing Company.
Coon, Carleton S.
1976 (1951) Caravan: The Story of the Middle East.
Huntington: Robert E. Krieger Publishing
Company.
Cooper, Merian C.
1925 Grass. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons.
Cribb, Roger.
1991 Nomads in Archaeology. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
de Planhol, Xavier.
1966 Aspects of Mountain Life in Anatolia and
Iran. In S. R. Eyre & Glanville R. J. Jones
(eds.) Geography as Human Ecology:
Methodology by Example: 291-308. New
York: St. Martin’s Press.
de Schauensee, Maude.
1968 Portable Architecture. Expedition 10: 32-39.
Delougaz, Pinhas.
1952 Pottery from the Diyala Region. Chicago:
University of Chicago Press.
Druc, Isabelle C.
1998 Ceramic Production and Distribution in the
Chavin Sphere of Influence (North -Central
Andes). John and Erica Hedges and
Archaeopress, S731.
Dyson, Jr., Robert.
1962 The Hasanlu Project. Science 135: 637-647.
Dyson Jr., Robert H & T. Cuyler Young Jr.
1960 The Solduz Valley, Iran: Pisdeli Tepe.
Antiquity 34: 19-28.
Ferring, C. Reid & Timothy K. Perttula.
1987 Defining the Provenance of Red Slipped
Pottery from Texas and Oklahoma by
Petrographic Methods. Journal of
Archaeological Science 14: 437-456.
Fisher, W. B.
1968 The Cambridge History of Iran vol. I.
Cambridge University Press.
Galbraith, Jane & Michael Roaf.
2001 Does the Neutron Activation Analysis of
Halaf pottery provide evidence of trade? A
re-examination of Davidson and McKerrell’s
investigation of Halaf pottery from the
Khabur basin in eastern Syria. London:
School of Economics and Political Science
Research Report.
Gibson, McGuire.
1981a Introduction. In Gibson, McGuire (eds.) Uch
Tepe I: Tell Razuk, Tell Ahmed al- Mughir,
Tell Ajamat. Baghdad: The State Organization
of Antiquities and Heritage.
1981b Geographical and Historical Background.
In Gibson, McGuire (ed.) Uch Tepe I: Tell
Razuk, Tell Ahmed al-Mughir, Tell Ajamat:
11-27. Baghdad: The State Organization of
Antiquities and Heritage.
Hamlin, Carol.
1975 Dalma Tepe. Iran 13: 111-127.
Hancock, Ronald G. V; Stuart J. Fleming & William D.
Glanzman.
1989 Analysis of Neolithic Iranian Ceramics.
Archaeological Chemistry 4: 113-124.
Henrickson, Elizabeth F.
1983 Ceramic Form and Function: An Ethnographic
Search and an Archaeological Application.
American Anthropologist 85: 630-643.
1985 The Early Development of Pastoralism in the
Central Zagros Highlands (Luristan). Iranica
Antiqua 20: 1-42.
Henrickson, Elizabeth F & Vanda Vitali.
1987 The Dalma Tradition: Prehistoric Inter-
Regional Cultural Integration in Highland
Western Iran. Paleorient 13: 37-45.
Hole, Frank.
1974 Tepe Tula’i, an early campsite in Khuzistan,
Iran. Paleorient 2: 219-242.
1978 Pastoral Nomadism in Western Iran.
In Richard A. Gould (ed.) Explorations in
Ethnoarcaheology: 127 - 167. Albuquerque:
University of Nw Mexico Press.
1980 The Prehistory of Herding: Some Suggestions
from Ethnography. In M. T. Barrelet (ed.)
L’archeologie de l’Iraq du debut de l’epoque
neolithique a 333 avant notre ere: 119-127.
Paris: Editions du CNRS.
1987a Archaeology of the Village Period. In Frank
Hole (ed.) The Archaeology of Western Iran:
Settlement and Society from Prehistory to
the Islamic Conquest: 29-78. Washington D.C:
Smithsonian Institution Press.
1987b Chronologies in the Iranian Neolithic.
In Olivier Aurenche; Jacques Evin & Francis
Hours (eds.) Chronologies in the Near
East: Relative Chronologies and Absolute
Chronology 16,000 - 4,000 B. P : 353-379.
Lyon.
1987c Settlement and Society in the Village Period.
In Frank Hole (ed.) The Archaeology of
Western Iran: Settlement and Society from
Prehistory to the Islamic Conquest: 79-105.
Washington, D C: Smithsonian Institution
Press.
Johnson, Douglas L.
1969 The Nature of Nomadism: A Comparative
Study of Pastoral Migrations in
Southwestern Asia and Northern Africa 118.
Chicago: Department of Geography,University
of Chicago.
Katsarou, Stella; Adamantios Sampson & Eleftheria
Dimou.
2002 Obsidian as Temper in the Neolithic
Pottery from Yiali, Greece. In Kilikoglou,
Vassilis; Anno Hein & Yannis Maniatis (eds.)
Modern Trends in Scientific Studies on
Ancient Ceramics: 111-120. Oxford:
Archaeopress.
Khazanov, Anatoly M.
1984 Nomads and the Outside World. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press.
Kramer, Carol.
1977 Pots and Peoples. In Louis D. Levine,
& T. Cuyler Young Jr. (eds.) Mountains and
Lowlands: Essays in the Archaeology of
Greater Mesopotamia: 91-112. Malibu:
Undena Publications.
Lees, Susan & Daniel G. Bates.
1974 The Origins of Specialized Nomadic
Pastoralism: A Systemic Model. American
Antiquity 39: 187-193.
Levine, Louise D & T. Cuyler Young Jr.
1984 A Summary of the Ceramic Assemblages of
the Central Western Zagros from the Middle
Neolithic to the Late Third Millennium B.C.
In Huot, Jean - Louis (ed.) Colloques
Internationaux CNRS: Prehistoire de la
Mesopotamie 1984: 15-53. Paris.
Levy, Thomas Evan.
1983 The Emergence of Specialized Pastoralism in
the Southern Levant. World Archaeology 15:
15-36.
Lombard, James P.
1987 Provenance of Sand Temper in Hohokam
Ceramics, Arizona. Geoarchaeology 2:
91-119.
Longacre, William A.
1970 Archaeology as Anthropology: A Case Study.
Tucson: University of Arizona Press.
McDonald, Mary.
1979 An Examination of Mid-Holocene Settlement
Patterns in the Central Zagros Region of
Western Iran. Dissertation. University of
Toronto.
Merpert, Nicolaï Y & Rauf M. Munchaev.
1993 Yarim Tepe I. In Norman Yoffee & Jeffrey
Clark (eds.) Early Stages in the Evolution
of Mesopotamian Civilization: Soviet
Excavations in Northern Iraq: 73-114. Tucson:
The University of Arizona Press.
Neff, Hector; Ronald L. Bishop & Edward V. Sayre.
1988 A Simulation Approach to the Problem of
Tempering in Compositional Studies of
Archaeological Ceramics. Journal of
Archaeological Science 15: 159-172.
1989 More Observations on the Problem of
Tempering in Compositional Studies of
Archaeological Ceramics. Journal of
Archaeological Science 16: 57-69.
Oates, David & Joan Oates.
1976 The Rise of Civilization. Oxford: Elsevier-
Phaidon.
Oates, Joan.
1983 Ubaid Mesopotamia Reconsidered. In T.
Cuyler Young Jr., & Philip E. L. Smith (eds.)
The Hilly Flanks and Beyond: Essays on the
Prehistory of Southwestern Asia: 251-282.
Chicago: The Oriental Institute of the
University of Chicago.
Oberlander, Theodore.
1965 The Zagros Streams: A New Interpretation of
Transverse Drainage in an Orogenic Zone.
Syracuse: Syracuse University Press.
Olin, Jacqueline S; Garman Harbottle & Edward V.
Sayre.
1978 Elemental Compositions of Spanish and
Spanish-Colonial Majolica Ceramics in the
Identification of Provenience. In Giles F
Carter (ed.) Archaeological Chemistry II:
200 - 229. Washington D. C: American
Chemical Society.
Olin, Jacqueline S & Edward V. Sayre.
1979 Environmental and Technological Causes
of Variations in the Absolute Concentrations
of Elements in Ceramics. Proceedings of
on the 18th International Symposium
Archaeometry and Archaeological
Prospection: 607. Bonn, 14-17 March 1978.
Koln: Archaeo - Physika. Rheinland - Verlag
GmbH.
Peacock, David P. S.
1967 The Heavy Mineral Analysis of Pottery: A
Preliminary Report. Archaeometry 10:
97-100.
Rands, Robert L & Ronald L. Bishop.
1980 Resource Procurement Zones and Patterns of
Ceramic Exchange in the Palenque Region,
Mexico. In Robert E. Fry (ed.) Models and
Methods in Regional Exchange: 19-46.
Washington D. C: Society for American
Archaeology.
Rice, Prudence M.
1987 Pottery Analysis: A Sourcebook. Chicago:
The University of Chicago Press.
Rye, Owen.
1981 Pottery Technology: Principles and
Reconstruction. Washington, D. C: Taraxacum.
Salzman, Phlip C.
1972 Multi - Resource Nomadism in Iranian
Baluchistan. In William Irons & Dyson-
Hudson Neville (eds.) Perspectives on
Nomadism: 60-68. Leiden: E. J. Brill.
Schubert, P.
1986 Petrographic Modal Analysis . A Necessary
Complement to Chemical Analysis of
Ceramic Coarse Ware. Archaeometry 28:
163-178.
Shepard, Anna O.
1936 The Technology of Pecos Pottery. In Alfred
V Kidder & Anna O. Shepard (eds.) The
Pottery of Pecos: 389-636. New Haven: Yale
University Press.
1985 Ceramics for the Archaeologist. Washington
DC: Carnegie Institution of Washington.
Skibo, James M; Michael B. Schiffer & Kenneth
C. Reid.
1989 Organic-Tempered Pottery: An Experimental
Study. American Antiquity 54: 122-146.
Smith, Philip E. L.
1986 Palaeolithic Archaeology in Iran.
Philadelphia: The University Museum,
University of Pennsylvania.
Solecki, Rose L & Ralph S. Solecki.
1973 Tepe Seavan: A Dalma Period Site in the
Margavar Valley, Azerbaijan, Iran. Bulletin of
the Asia Institute 3: 98-116.
Spooner, Brian.
1973 The Cultural Ecology of Pastoral Nomads.
Addison-Wesley module in anthropology 45.
Stein, Sir Aurel.
1940 Old Routes of Western Iran: Narrative of an
Archaeological Journey Carried out and
Recorded by Sir Aurel Stein, K.C.I.E. London:
Macmillan and Co., Limited.
Stewart, Ian M.
1973 Microstructural Studies Using the Electron
Microprobe Analyzer. In James L McCall &
William M. Mueller (eds.) MicrostructuralAnalysis: Tools and Techniques: 281-285.
New York: Plenum Press.
Stoltman, James B.
1989 A Quantitative Approach to the Petrographic
Analysis of Ceramic Thin Sections. American
Antiquity 54: 147-160.
1991 Ceramic Petrography as a Technique for
Documenting Cultural Interaction: An
Example from the Upper Mississippi Valley.
American Antiquity 56: 103-120.
Stoltman, James B; Joyce Marcus; Kent V. Flannery;
James H. Burton & Robert G. Moyle.
2005 Petrographic evidence shows that pottery
exchange between the Olmec and their
neighbors was two - way. Proceedings of the
National Academy of Sciences of the United
States of America 102: 11213-11218.
Streily, A. Hansen.
2000 Early pottery kilns in the Middle East.
Paleorient 26: 69-81.
Thuesen, Ingold; E. Oldensburg & K. Jorgensen.
1989 Microscope Section Analysis of Pottery.
Paleorient 15: 273-278.
Tonoike, Yukiko.
2010 Beyond Style: etrographic Analysis of
Dalma Ceramics from Two Regions in Iran.
Diissertation. Yale University.
Tsolakidou, Alexandra; Peter M. Day; Evangelia
Kiriatzi & Vassilis Kilikoglou.
2002 Investigating Petrological and Chemical
Groupings of Early Minoan Cooking Vessels.
In Vassilis Kilikoglou; Anno Hein & Yannis
Maniatis (eds.) Modern Trends in Scientific
Studies on Ancient Studies: Papers Presented
at the 5th European Meeting on Ancient
Ceramics, Athens, 1999: 19-33. Oxford:
Archaeopress.
Ullens de Schooten, Marie-Therese.
1956 Lords of the Mountains: Southern Persia and
the Kashkai Tribe. London: Chatto&Windus.
van Zeist, Willem & Sytze Bottema.
1982 Vegetational History of the Eastern
Mediterranean and the Near East During the
Last 20,000 Years. In John L. Bintliff (ed.) Palaeoclimates, Palaeoenviroments and
Human Communities in the Eastern
Mediterranean Region in Later Prehistory:
277-321. Oxford: BAR.
Vandiver, Pamela B.
1985 Sequential Slab Construction: A Near
Eastern Pottery Production Technology,
8000-3000 BC. Massachusetts Institute of
Technology.
1987 Sequential Slab Construction: A Conservative
Southwest Asiatic Ceramic Tradition, ca.
7000-3000 BC. Paleorient 13: 9-35.
1988 The Implications of Variation in Ceramic
Technology: The Forming of Neolithic
Storage Vessels in China and the Near East.
Archaeomaterials 2: 139-174.
Voigt, Mary M.
1977 The Subsistence Economy of a Sixth
Millennium Village in the Ushnu-Solduz
Valley. In Louis D Levine & T. Cuyler Young
Jr (eds.) Mountains and Lowlands: Essays in
the Archaeology of Greater Mesopotamia 7:
307-346.Undena Publications.
Voigt, Mary M & Robert H. Dyson.
1992 Iran. In Robert W. Ehrich (ed.) Chronologies
in Old World Archaeology II: 125-178.
University of Chicago Press.
Watson, Patty Jo.
1966 Clues to Iranian Prehistory in Modern Village
Life. Expedition 8: 9-19.
1979 Archaeological Ethnography in Western Iran.
Tucson: The University of Arizona Press.
Whitbread, Ian K.
1989 A Proposal for the Systematic Description of
Thin Sections Towards the Study of Ancient
Ceramic Technology. In Yannis Maniatis
(ed.) Archaeometry: Proceedings of the
25th International Symposium: 127-138.
Amsterdam: Elsevier Science Publishers BV.
1995 Greek Transport Amphorae: A Petrological
and Archaeological Study. Athens: British
School at Athens.
Whitbread, Ian K; Evangelia Kiriatzi & Thomas
Tartaron.
2002 Middle Bronze Age Ceramic Production in
Central and Southern Mainland Greece: The
Design of a Regional Petrographic Study. In
Kilikoglou, Vassilis; Anno Hein & Yannis
Maniatis (eds.) Modern Trends in Scientific
Studies on Ancient Studies: Papers Presented
at the 5th European Meeting on Ancient
Ceramics, Athens, 1999: 121-128. Oxford:
Archaeopress.
Williams, David F.
1983 Petrology of Ceramics. In David R. C Kempe
& Anthony P. Harvey (eds.) The Petrology of
Archaeological Artefacts: 301 - 329. Oxford:
Clarendon Press.
Young Jr, T. Cuyler.
1967 Survey of Excavations in Iran During 1965-
1966. Iran 5: 139-140.
1974 An Archaeological Survey of the Kangavar
Valley. In Firouz Bagherzadeh (ed.)
Proceedings of the IIIrd Annual Symposium
on Archaeological Research in Iran, 2nd-7th
November 1974: 23-30. Tehran: Iranian Centre
for Archaeological Research.
Young, Jr., T. Cuyler & Louis D. Levine.
1974 Excavations of the Godin Project: Second
Progress Report. Ontario: Royal Ontario
Museum.
Zohary, Daniel.
1969 The progenitors of wheat and barley in
relation to domestication and agricultural
dispersal in the Old World. In Peter J Ucko
& Geoffrey W. Dimbleby (eds.) The
Domestication and Exploitation of Plants and
Animals: 47-66.London: Duckworth.